A Masashi Wakui look with GIMP

You are right, you could do it with just the curve.

That is basically a personal preference and the way I did it at the time of writing the tutorial…:slight_smile:
What I liked to do at that time is to set a general tone on the duplicated layer and then afterwards look if I want this tone applied only to deepest shadows, or all the shadows using luminosity masks.

1 Like