2 posts were split to a new topic: what’s so hard about darktable
Your reply sounds like it responds to two people @Duecki1 proposed the project and @bestman8 mentioned their take on DT…
@Duecki1 welcome to the forum. Good luck with the project. It is really nice to see when people put the effort in to develop their own solution for editing that they are willing to freely share it.
I am on Windows at the moment so I can’t test your software. A couple of screen shots of your software and an example of an edit would be nice to see. It would also be good if you used your software on some of the PlayRaws that get posted in this forum so we can compare the results you obtain.
It’s nice to have a simple raw editor than DT. I like Rapid Raw as I want to introduce this kind of culling and editing simple software to a beginner. CalibRaw also has the potential to be a supplement to DT.
When I export the image second time, it already has the same file and it does not have a choice to create another duplicate automatically (eg adding -01 to the file name). It will be great if it can duplicate + a notification message.
I think whats missing from a lot of these new Raw editors is a proper Digital Asset manager like what Lightroom has or Darktable. That would set you apart from the likes of Rapidraw , Safelight , HappyPhoton etc…
I agree that darktable is not the answer to everything!
I just find it curious that people invest a ton of time is learning about image processing from scratch, because they found darktable too hard…
But of course everyone is free to use whatever they want
I think this a great suggestion.
Ok, people want to attract new users to their software. They should at least show off a bit what they software is capable. The play raw is a great place for that.
Just to bring more light to some people’s reaction here.
Every week we get a new AI vibed raw editor in this forum, and their creators are inviting us to test it out.
No problem, some people are willing to do that.
But someone of us will come with questions like: how is your new tool really different to what already exists? Why didn’t you just contribute to what already exists? What guarantees do you give us your software will not be abandoned within a month? Do you understand any of the theory behind raw development?
I think this is a valid reaction as long isn’t done in a mean way.
No matter how the discussion goes, a new project always brings new hope - and a chance to improve, optimize, and modernize the pipeline ![]()
I’ve never been able to settle down with the proper DAM solution. Mainly because I prefer to keep my photos in ‘event’ folders. That’s why edits are more important to me than management. But some may disagree and prefer fully-fledged DAM solution before edits. That’s why choice is so important, especially if you can chain tools together.
I’ve kinda reached the point where I don’t want to test things anymore. The rendering and the way the sliders work are all very similar in each of apps these dev’s post. Even when do find a stable app or one thats been out for a while , your one update away from things breaking. Over on reddit some subreddits have begun cracking down on vibe coded apps due to the onslaught.
Very likely. I do that.
Cloudy brain. But I also think of forum threads as conversations in which a post may do more than reply to specifics.
At least that’s my excuse. Multi-Quote is indeed better than Cloudy Brain!
I haven’t dipped into creating my own raw editor, but I have spent a lot of time working on my own method for converting film datasheets into AgX presets, when I could have just gone and used something like spektrafilm. For me it is one of the most enjoyable things about the hobby: figuring out odd little systems of my own… Maybe OP is similar.
I think this is the 6th very similar looking editors since RapidRaw. Two I really like at face value are LightTable and Safelight. If we receive anymore I will need a matrix layout to decide which one to invest time in!
I just opened CalibRaw (its a very small size software) and hit a problem straight away - unable to open dng files. I will report this on github. Of course this might be me…
I only mentioned it for possible clarity…I’m lucky if I don’t respond to myself ![]()
Heh, me too… ![]()
Thing is, wasn’t that darktable was too hard, it just didn’t do things the way I wanted. Particularly sidecars, didn’t want that if I could help it. And help it I did…
Building rawproc compelled me to learn specifics about each and every operation. That learning has been invaluable to my photography; I use a lot of the automation in capturing, not just because it was easy to do, but more that I understood what it could and could not do for me. For instance, I tried all manner of ETTR pet tricks, didn’t find a way to use it in my grab-shot life, but highlight-weighted metering came close enough to work with in the post-processing toolchain I understood, cool beans, one less thing to distract me from composition.
What I worry for the AI-assisted endeavors of recent is that they come to rely too much on the black-box solutions and don’t dig enough into the principles to truly understand them, or even understand whatever the AI gave them to insure it is correct. No learning in that, and not-zero likelihood of implementing wrong algorithms…
Thank you very much :D. CalibRaw does have a windows release. Thanks for the idea and help ![]()
Here are some screenshots:
Here are two edited playraws:
(I added some glow here too)
and
And here a simple edit:
Before:
After:
Thank you for the feedback, I will fix that for the next release ![]()
I can fully understand that :). I did contribute to other open source RAW Editors for some time, but they just weren’t heading into the direction I was hoping for (more features, less bug fixing and no processing improvement mainly), that’s why I made a custom solution for me and my friends, even through it was way harder.
I’m using this software myself, so abandoning it is not my plan, but I do understand why one would be concerned about that.
And yes, i only understand a bit of the theory behind raw development. I’m still learning and wanting to improve as i continue to work on this project.
Thank you very much for testing and sorry about the dng problem :(.
I missed to mention the supported RAW formats in the readme. DNG is not supported right now, only RAWs out of (most) dedicated Cameras and tiff.
I’ve updated the readme to match, I’m planning to support DNG in the near future too.
@Duecki1 Great work on the editor! Did you use a native rust gui framework to overcome the Tauri framework limitations I notice on linux?






