I think you have missed the visual message here, though: there are even 3 carousels in this photo:
The statues that design a perfect oval in the plaza (Prato della Valle, look for that in Wikipedia).
The tourists (or the citizens of this town) walking around that exact oval with the burden of their daily lives.
The kids’ carousel in itself.
You probably would’t like to cut off anyone of the three layers with a crop.
You can also read the photo as a contrast “sacred/profane”, with Santa Giustina abbey in the background and a silly playground in the foreground… Both deserted.
I agree with @Claes – this is a difficult one, with the backlighting, the haze and the relatively low contrast overall. It was a real balancing act to get a little depth into it and I’m not sure I did it justice. I cropped a little bit of sky off since it wasn’t part of the story. I didn’t have the nerve (nor skill!) to go any more detailed with masking than I did…
Processed in ART 1.18.1, resized and exported in Affinity Photo.
I really like your interpretation. @Claes and @123sg, I agree that it was a difficult shot, with some problems that are difficult to fix, first of all the suboptimal framing.
Thanks @all.
I didn’t actually expect to find it difficult, but the contrast surprised me a bit. Thanks for the background about the location too. Very nice to know!
Oh, and I don’t know really know that I’d change the framing… I think it works well.
Hello, the last times that I visited Italy - regretfully too long ago - I always shot b&w, analogue. I guess it’s for that reason that my first idea with this photo was to make a b&w version. Somewhat dreamy. Done in ART.
Edit. Hmm, the photo in ART looks different than the one posted above, see for example the statue on the top/roof of the churches, in ART it’s black, not here above… Recently upgraded to Xubuntu 22.04, perhaps the problem lies there.
A great image. Thanks for sharing.
My try in GIMP. I have made local adjustments to brightness and contrast in an attempt to make the “galloper” stand out from the background.
All black and white except the carrousel
For the frame (with carousel color) I had to move the colorize module up above the monochrome modules in the pipeline.
And for the blur, I was hoping that in the blur1 module, selecting the figure used in Monochrome1 would also select the parametric mask (I thought it was included). As it was not, I had to select by hand the parametric mask in blur1 to blur only the background.
(deepL)