Problems with halo in BW

I stupidly overexposed this shot by measuring on the skin. As a result the left half of the image was basically all white when checking in dt. After some processing (especailly tone-equalizer) I got my contrasts how I wanted them but produced the very visible halo.

Where did I fuck-up (except exposure metering ;o) and what can I do better?

Yes I could pass on this one and concentrate on other shots, but I like her sensual expression and the intimacy of this shot, so … H E L P !

(I can and will send you the RAW file per WeTransfer if you have a solution, but this is NOT a play Raw competition. This is about losing the halo that I stupidly created)

Have you tried to switch around the “preserve details” options in tone equalizer? I have found that they are often responsible for halos.

2 Likes

Often just tweaking the edge refinement slider up a little is all you need…try 5%… not sure what your current settings are…

1 Like

Yeah these settings can make tremendous differences.

Often it helps, to not make too steep of a gradient. Better stack two instances of the tone eq with slightly lower gradients.

1 Like

For what it’s worth, though, I don’t think the halo negatively effects the image — seeing as how the model is so attractive and so well posed, and how well the overall tone of the image comes across, it doesn’t detract my attention. In short, I think it’s a great shot regardless (mind you, I’ve always thought all your images are amazing :+1:).

1 Like

I could be worth displaying the mask in tone equalizer and cycling through the preserve detail options as this may reveal the source of the halos. I would recommend this exercise at least once for all users of the tone equalizer module to appreciate the difference that comes form the preserve details options.

2 Likes

Yes, by switching that to “no” I got a way better result, thanks

thanks (getting all red, looking at my shoes)

1 Like

yes, switching preserve detail to “nope” helped a lot.

We are all here to learn and ask for advice. I only recently discovered the power of looking at the masks and the different preserve detail options. Reading the manual on this feature was also interesting for me. I am also a big fan of the shadow and highlights module which I do not see tone equalizer as a replacement for. They work and look different and I often use both in the same edit. With the shadow and highlights module if I get halos I switch the softening option to bilateral filter and this seems to always resolve the problem.

You should repost the updated result… :slight_smile: did that also fix the hip area …seems like her right hip sort of blended into the background a bit too much??

OK, here we are - with a lot less of a halo