Looks correct to me. “Clear” means “apply neutral” when you have dynamic profiles. What you want is “Reset to default”.
Please share such images, otherwise it’s hard to understand what is going on…
I think you need to get used to the logic of how profiles rules are applied. Specifically, the rules are applied top to bottom, so later ones can override the earlier ones. That means that highest priority rules should go last in the list.
So, simply try moving the new rules to the bottom. Furthermore, the one for the EF70-300 should go after the other one, otherwise for shots taken at 70mm they will both match, and the profile for the sigma will be applied.
HTH