Luminosity Masking in darktable

(system) #1

Luminosity Masking in darktable

Making targeted adjustments to your RAWs

Luminosity Masking, the ability to create selections of your image based on its specific tones for ultra-targeted editing, is a relatively recent concept favoured by landscape photographers the world over. In this article, we will explore how to create and use Luminosity Masks in the F/OSS RAW editor darktable, so that you can make adjustments on your RAW files to isolated tones.

What is Luminosity Masking?

Luminosity Masking is a technique developed in the last 10 years or so primarily by American Southwest landscape photographer Tony Kuyper over at goodlight.us. Tony provides extensive writing and information on Luminosity Masking and how to create Luminosity Masks; in this article I’ll be primarily focusing and creating and using the masks in darktable, but if you want to really understand the basics I highly recommend giving Tony’s guide a good read over first.

In essence, Luminosity Masking is about creating highly specific selections of your photo based on the tones of the image itself. This enables you to have extremely fine control over what parts of the photo are selected to make adjustments on (such as contrast, saturation etc.) whilst keeping other tones of the photo completely unaffected. Let’s quickly illustrate this with some screenshots.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Here’s a shot I got of the Coral Beach on the Isle of Skye, Scotland, when my partner and I toured there recently in October 2014. It’s a pretty solid exposure. Let’s have a look at the histogram.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

This article assumes you already have a basic understanding of histograms and how they work but I’ll give a quick summary here: the histogram represents the tonal information of your photo. It’s a graph of the light. On the left-hand side of the histogram is where all the Shadow information is, all the darker tones of the image. On the right-hand side you’ll find all the Highlight information, the brighter tones. And therefore, towards the middle of the histogram, is where all your midtones are located. The taller the graph is in a certain section of your histogram, the more information there is. So for this photo, you can see that we have a lot of shadow and highlight information, but hardly any midtones. We’re also not clipping (losing information) any shadows and highlights as well i.e. the graph isn’t flattened against either side of the histogram. So we’ve got plenty of room to work with here.

So let’s say that I feel the sky is a little too bright and I want to darken it. The day was quite overcast at this point and the sky in this image feels too washed out. Let’s darken it by dropping the exposure.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Now we’re starting to see some more definition in the sky but the image overall feels too dingy and dark. Let’s look at the histogram.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

As you can see, underneath the histogram I have the Exposure module open and I’ve pulled the exposure of the photo down by -1.02EV, darkening the image. This is reflected in the histogram. What was previously highlight information has been brought down so that it now resides in the midtones of the photo. This has brought back some definition and colour to the sky but now the rest of the photo is too dark; you can see on the histogram that the shadow information is bundling up on the left-hand side and we’re in danger of clipping the shadows, that is, losing information, which would result in blotches of pure black in the photo. Not good.

How do we get around this? Well, we create and use a Luminosity Mask that selects just the highlights in the photo, mostly the sky, but leaves the rest of the photo alone, keeping the shadows where they are. Here’s the result of using a Luminosity Mask to darken just the highlights in the photo.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Much better. We’ve darkened the highlights, the sky, bringing back some colour and definition but have left the shadows, the beach and grass, well alone. Let’s see how our histogram is doing.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Once again, I’ve opened up the Exposure module and dropped the exposure of the photo down to -1.02EV but you can see that the module looks a little different this time. That’s because I’ve applied a Luminosity Mask to the Exposure change. We’ll come back to that in a bit. Look at the histogram in the top-right. We’ve brought the highlights down into the midtones but kept the shadows where they are. We can make another targeted adjustment if we want. Let’s say that I want to brighten the shadows a little bit as well.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Ah-ha! Now we’re bringing back some clarity and interest to the foreground, that lovely sweeping curve of the grass, beach and loch, with the hill in the distance. Check out the histogram.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

You can see at the bottom-right that I’ve made a new adjustment, known as “Exposure 1”, where I’ve increased the exposure of the image by 0.72EV. But again, I’ve applied a Luminosity Mask to this adjustment so that the brightening effect only happens to the shadows in the photo, leaving the highlights alone. In the histogram, you’ll note that we now have a lot of midtone information, by darkening the highlights and brightening the shadows. Tony Kuyper talks alot about the “Magic Midtones” and for good reason: the midtones are the real meat of the photo and applying targeted adjustments to the midtones of a photo can really take your work to the next level.

So, let’s review the changes we’ve made to this photo.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial
Fig. 1: Original RAW
Fig. 2: Whole photo darkened
Fig. 3: Highlights darkened only
Fig. 4: Shadows brightened as well

And let’s also look at how the histogram has changed.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial
Fig. 5: Original RAW
Fig. 6: Whole photo darkened
Fig. 7: Highlights darkened only
Fig. 8: Shadows brightened as well

Creating Luminosity Masks in darktable

Luminosity Masking is easy to do in darktable; it’s built right in to the software since v1.4 (and now we’re on v1.6). Every single module in darktable, whether that’s Contrast, Vibrance, Exposure etc., can have a Luminosity Mask applied to it for targeted adjustments. Let’s demonstrate on a new image.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Here’s a shot I grabbed on that same tour of Scotland in October 2014, this time of the Glenfinnan Monument. Pretty neat? If you look at the histogram at the top-right, you’ll see that I have a lot of shadow information (in fact it’s almost clipping) and I have a good range of highlight information that moves into the midtones as well. Thankfully there’s no clipping going on but the photo is too dark, with the monument and mountains appearing almost as shadowy silhouettes against the sky. What we want to do is to brighten up those shadows to bring back the details and colour in the monument and the mountains. We may also do a smidgen of highlight darkening as well.

So, let’s open the Exposure module and I’ll walk us through it.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

You can find the Exposure module in the Basic Group, represented by the hollow white circle icon.

The magic we’re looking for is under the “blend” dropdown:

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Simply select “parametric mask”. This is where the magic is. In my view, it should be renamed to Luminosity Mask, but that’s just me.

This is where we can create a mask of the photo by selecting just certain tonal ranges. Now, we’re not going to go into detail on every aspect of this masking system; I’ll leave to you to experiment with. Just note that this “parametric mask” function is available in every darktable module, so you can apply Luminosity Masks on Exposure, Saturation, Contrast, Vibrance, Local Contrast… whatever you wish. This is neat and very powerful.

So, next step: select the “L” tab for “Luminosity” – located on the far right of the other tabs “g”, “R”, “G”, “B”, “H”, “S” — and then select the little icon that has the black circle in the white square, this will show the mask.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

This is what your photo will now look like.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Don’t panic!

All this yellow is telling you is that, currently, any Exposure adjustment you make will take effect on the whole photo. Clearly, this isn’t what we want. What we’re going to do is adjust the Input slider to start narrowing down our selection to just the tones we want; in this case, we’re after the shadows so we can brighten them up whilst leaving the highlights alone. We can do this by bringing the sliders on the right-hand side of the Input slider down towards the left. This will start deselecting the highlights of the photo as we narrow our mask further towards the shadows.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

As you can see, I’ve brought the Input sliders from the right-hand side down to 25, very close to the left-hand sliders. This is reflected in the mask, as we’re now starting to deselect some of the brighter highlights in the sky. But we want to narrow it down further so that we’re targeting just the darkest parts of the photo: the mountains, foreground and monument.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Boom! We’ve had to bring the sliders down all the way to 5 to cut off the highlights in the sky. We’ve also managed to deselect some of the brighter highlights in the foreground as well. Let’s just make one final adjustment to the sliders before we start brightening the Exposure.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Here, all we’ve done is move the bottom right-hand slider back up towards the highlights a little bit. What this does is feather and soften the mask so that when we do our Exposure brightening it will look more natural and blend better.

OK, we’ve got our initial mask targeted nicely towards the shadows; hide the mask by selecting that black circle in the white square icon again. Now it’s time to start brightening up the Exposure.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Boom! Much better. Let’s do a side-by-side comparison.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial
Fig. 9: Original RAW unedited
Fig. 10: Foreground, monument and mountains (shadow areas) have been brightened through a Luminosity Mask, leaving the highlights in the sky alone.

Already, we’ve made a striking change to how the photo looks. There’s now a lot more interest as our subject, the monument, is much brighter with plenty of details available. However, we’re not quite done. The sky to the right of the monument looks a bit… funky. That’s because when we feathered our Luminosity Mask a bit we selected too much highlight information. This has resulted in part of the sky getting brighter but the rest of the sky staying the same, which looks strange. We can correct this by moving the bottom right-hand slide back to the left a bit, cutting off those highlights in the sky more.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Better. By moving the bottom right-hand slider back down from 20 to 8 the sky looks more natural.

Already, this photo is looking a lot better. Let’s take some of those bright highlights in the sky and darken them a bit, so that the eye isn’t distracted and focuses more on the monument. To do this, we’re going to make another Exposure adjustment.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

To the left of the Exposure module name you’ll see four little icons. Click the rightmost one and then select “New Instance” in the dropdown that appears.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

We now have a new module called “Exposure 1” that sits on top of our previous Exposure module. With this Exposure 1, we’re going to create a Luminosity Mask targeting the highlights so that we can darken the exposure in them.

Same process as before: in “Exposure 1” select the “blend” dropdown then select “parametric mask”.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Select the “L” tab for Luminosity then make the mask visible by clicking on the black circle in the white square icon.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

This time, we’re going to take the left-hand sliders and bring them to the right, slowly deselecting the shadows until we’ve targeted the highlight tones we want to darken.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

In our example, we’ve taken the left-hand sliders of Input up to 17 and then brought the bottom left-hand Input slider back down a little to 6 so that we feather the mask out for a more seamless blend.

Let’s start decreasing the exposure to see what it looks like. Just click on the black circle in the white square icon again to hide the mask and starting decreasing the exposure slider.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Nice! Here, we’ve brought the exposure down by -0.50EV through our Luminosity Mask, targeting the highlights and darkening them. We’ve also tweaked the bottom left-hand slider by bringing it down to 3 for a bit more feathering.

Here’s a before and after.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial
Fig 11: Shadows brightened only via a Luminosity Mask
Fig 12: Brightest highlights darkened through a Luminosity Mask in a new exposure adjustment.

Giggedy. So this photo is starting to look pretty sweet. Let’s just make one more adjustment, globally this time with no Luminosity Mask. I want to generally increase the overall exposure of the photo.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Good! As you can see, on the right-hand side I’ve created another Exposure module, now called “exposure 2” and have increased the overall exposure of the photo by 0.50EV.

To round up this tutorial, let’s look into making one more adjustment through Luminosity Masks. Now that we’ve brightened up the shadows and darkened down the highlights, we’ve moved a lot of the tones in the photo towards the midtones. This is where the real meat of the image is. We can now really give this photo some punch and pop by applying some contrast to just the midtones of the image. Here’s how.

Open the Contrast, Brightness & Saturation module, select “blend” then select the “parametric mask” option in the dropdown.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

You’ll note this time round that the tabs in the module—the “L”, “a”, “b”, “C” and “h”—are different to the Exposure module. Don’t worry. Just leave the “L” for Luminosity selected. We’re now going to adjust the Input sliders so that we’re targeting just the midtones of the photo. We do this by deselecting both the highlights and shadows. This is done by moving the left-hand sliders up and the right-hand sliders down towards the middle.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

So here’s how my midtones Luminosity Mask looks. On the right, you can see that I’ve brought the sliders towards the middle and then dropped the bottom slider of the pair away so that there’s some feathering. This is quite a tight midtones mask but that’s OK. Now let’s hide the mask and start increasing the contrast.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial

Much better. Because we’re only targeting a tight selection of the midtones we can make quite an aggressive contrast adjustment (I’ve brought the contrast slider way up to 50). I’ve also increased the brightness of the midtones a little, pulled down the saturation to compensate for the contrast adjustment, and also increased the blurring of the mask to 100, feathering out the mask further for a more natural adjustment.

Let’s look at the before and after.

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial
Fig. 13: Our RAW with the shadows brightened and the highlights darkened
Fig. 14: Contrast increased in the midtones through a Luminosity Mask

You can see the biggest difference this contrast adjustment made was to the texture in the foreground grass and the stone detail in the monument. You can make out the individual clumps of growth in the foreground as well as the individual tones in the stone of the monument. Neat.

Finally, here’s an overview of the adjustments we’ve made to this photo

Ian Hex darktable luminosity mask tutorial
Fig. 15: Original unedited RAW
Fig. 16: Shadows brightened through a Luminosity Mask
Fig. 17: Highlights darkened through a Luminosity Mask
Fig. 18: Overall exposure increased a little, no mask
Fig. 19: Contrast in the midtones increased through a Luminosity Mask.

Conclusion

In this tutorial, I’ve only gone through the very basics of what is possible with darktable’s Luminosity Masks, so that one can make subtle adjustments to the shadows, highlights and midtones of their photo in order to balance the image better. But Luminosity Masks can be used for so much more and so I invite you to experiment! Try out the different modules available in darktable and see how you can apply various filters through different masks to achieve highly-specific adjustments to your RAWs like never before.


This is a companion discussion topic for the original entry at https://pixls.us/articles/luminosity-masking-in-darktable/
5 Likes

(James Elliman) #2

This is a really good write up, very clear. Thanks! Is this feature available in Light room under another name? Cheers

2 Likes

#3

Thanks for writing this article Ian, I found it most useful, keep up the great work.

1 Like

(Ian Hex) #4

Hi James. As far as I’m aware, Lightroom has no ability to create luminosity masks, making Darktable rather unique!

0 Likes

(Ian Hex) #5

Ta very much, 'tis definitely appreciated.

0 Likes

(keith) #6

Thanks Ian for such a clear and informative article.

Look forward to more :smile:

1 Like

(Ian Hex) #7

There’ll be plenty more, trust me.

0 Likes

(Carmelo Dr Raw) #8

PhotoFlow allows to create and apply luminosity masks in a way that is, at least conceptually, similar to darktable: http://photoflowblog.blogspot.fr/2014/09/tutorial-creating-and-using-luminosity.html

However, luminosity masks are in this case associated to layers, instead of directly to tools…

1 Like

(Stijn De Loose) #9

Thanks for the tutorial! Very informative!

One thing that bothers me is that the clouds on the right side of the tower end up looking quite unnatural. Is there a way to remedy that?

Thanks!

Stijn

0 Likes

(Pat David) #10

Through a combination of adjusting the sky masks + exposure modifications. That is, soften the modifications in the sky wherever you may find them “unnatural” looking and/or add another mask to control the results in that region.

1 Like

(Stijn De Loose) #11

Thanks! Will give it a try.

1 Like

(KV Subbaiah Setty) #12

wow ! excellent tutorial ,I just started using Draktable and this article opened lot of inner workings of DT ,especially the masking power of it. thanks a lot and every article here is forcing me to shift from LR to DT

2 Likes

(Isaac Ullah) #13

Thanks for the great tutorial! One question: is this method fundamentally different than just adjusting the tone curve? Or adjusting the highlights, gamma, and shadows in the color balance module? Thanks!

1 Like

(Pat David) #14

Hi @Isaac!

I’m sure @LightSweep would love to hear that you like his tutorial! :slight_smile: The difference here vs. just adjusting a tone curve or lift, gamma, gain is that the results are targeted to specific regions of luminance. You can actually include a tone curve adjustment and then mask it to only effect the mid-tones (or high, low, etc…).

1 Like

(Isaac Ullah) #15

Ah, I see! That makes total sense. So this technique is “in addition to” rather than “in alternative to”. I suppose I’m still wrapping my head around all the possibilities! Thanks for your quick reply! And thanks to @LightSweep for the great tutorial!

1 Like

(Pat David) #16

Yeah, it can be overwhelming at first. Take your time, experiment, and don’t forget we’re here to share and help as well! :smiley:

1 Like

(Christian Kanzian) #17

Thank you very much for this tutorial @LightSweep!

It helped me to find the right direction, because I had a hart time with the shadows and highlights modul. Even with the bilateral filter it is not easy to prevent halos.

2 Likes

#18

Thank you very much for this tutorial, Ian. I’m a beginner and wondering how to use luminosity masks in Raw Therapee.

0 Likes

(Pat David) #19

Depending on what you wanted to do there may be some other options in RawTherapee for masking. I don’t think there’s an actual Luminosity Mask option available just yet.

0 Likes

(Mica) #20

Where are these options?

0 Likes