Thank you for sharing.
Not DarkTable. Filmulator and then GIMP. Removed the cables (although I was lazy and did not remove them where they crossed the roof!)
Adjustments to contrast and an increase in saturation - probably overdone.
2 Likes
Here’s my go - thanks for the great photo! DT 4.0, mostly obvious except maybe the channel mixer fiddling (my pet toy at the moment!) I haven’t done anything about the cables though. I’d like to see what the retouch module would do, but I’m on my laptop which is already groaning under the load of a couple of masks + the other modules.
IMG_9927.CR2.xmp (12.5 KB)
Now I’m seeing it along side others versions mine looks a bit cooler than I meant… I think I won’t change it though
1 Like
Thanks for sharing this nice view!
RT dev, wires removed in GIMP
IMG_9927_RT-3.jpg.out.pp3 (22.9 KB)
1 Like
I like the B&W although slightly too dark for my taste.
1 Like
Nice image, thanks for sharing!
I like your edit and decided to hijack it 
.
My main changes:
- Removed the dull halos on the church-walls against the sky by tweaking tone-equalizer curve a bit.
- removed chromatic abberations: CA-Module and lens correction
- retouched the telephone cables with dt
- added a bit more vibrance etc. with color balance rgb
IMG_9927.CR2.xmp (75.1 KB)
1 Like
Certainly some stunning edits. But it does look like I’ll get better retouching using Gimp to clone out the power lines rather than darktable.
Hello,
Here is a colourful version (DT 4.0), personally, I would leave the cables
IMG_9927.CR2.xmp (17.0 KB)
1 Like
My take, trying to create a dramatic look.
Didn’t spend time to clone out the cables
IMG_9927.CR2.xmp (19.1 KB)
1 Like
Great capture!
Here’s my edit in darktable 4.0, with a lot of stuff going on (I might’ve gone a little overboard):
IMG_9927.CR2.xmp (684.5 KB)
Let’s see, there’s:
- Wire removal using multiple copies of the retouch module.
- First, I focused on removing the wires by outlining the shape and using a mask to restrict it to the detailed parts (which finds the contrast of the wire to the sky), so it’s even more targeted. One module per wire because: why not?
- As I have to pick up parts of the sky for the whole wire, it looks a little odd in a few places after this, so I went back with another copy to retouch the sky afterward.
- Then, I made yet another instance of the module to remove the wire from the bricks, by finding corners of bricks that are similar enough and patch it in.
- Typical modules:
- denoise (profiled), to remove noise
- chromatic aberrations (to remove the color fringing from the lens, visible between the building and skies)
- A second instance of the color calibration module to darken the image based on the blue channel (and offset the darkness by bumping up blue and green to compensate)… This darkens the sky a good bit.
- Tone equalizer, two instances: first to adjust the scene overall, second to darken the bushes (more or less).
- Instances of “diffuse or sharpen” to: compensate for an AA filter, deblur the lens, and add a little bit of proper local contrast
- Instances of color balance rgb to bump up color, selectively adjust the red color of the church, increase the contrast of the cemetery and gravestones (using a feathered brush to select it), adjust the contrast of the sky, and one to add a bit of magenta/purple (to balance some color contrast against the green, as an “artistic choice”).
- Lastly, I use the local contrast module (which operates in LAB after everything else, so it’s not the best module to usually use) with a mask to only target the highlights of the sky, to add a bit more contrast drama.
For the color tinting of the sky (which is admittedly probably a bit overdone here), you can see the difference in the scope, where the purple is directly across from the green of the grass:
- before:
- after:
Apologies for those wanting to play around with this edit; it will really require a beefy computer with everything going on (especially with the “diffuse or sharpen” modules).
And here’s a super-vanilla version, where I basically removed everything but the wire removal. It’s probably a good starting point for anyone wanting to play with the image in darktable if they don’t want to mess with healing clone to remove the wires themselves. 
IMG_9927_01.CR2.xmp (61.5 KB)
2 Likes