Thank you for the clarification
Rugrats Season 2 episode “Garage Sale”:
Angelica: “Aunt Didi, what’s disco?”
Didi: “Oh, nothing, sweetheart. It’s something that happened a long time ago and it’s never, never coming back, so don’t you worry.”
Later in that same episode, after the babies accidentally sell all of the adults’ belongings:
Stu: “My Disco Suit… My 8-tracks… My stereo…”
Didi: “You know, Stu, maybe this isn’t such a bad thing. What we really lost were material possessions and what we’ve rediscovered are the important things. Like family and love and other real human values.”
Stu: (Deadpan) “Put a sock in it, Deed.”
I noticed disabling gamut clipping helps with letting the highlights reach more brightness. Is this by design? Judging from their tooltip and docs I would have not expected this.
thanks, there obviously was a wrong/too short tooltip. Fixed with spektrafilm: clarify gamut compression in tooltip by piratenpanda · Pull Request #22246 · darktable-org/darktable · GitHub
For lush greens gold200/Crystal paper is a very nice combination
.
fix in master now
Gold200+Endura Premier+no bandwidth adaptation, that is my go to for deep greens. I think that ended up being the foliage preset.
Another bug report
- Adjust print filtration Y
- Adjust print filtration M
- Press the reset button on the filtration segment
- Press ctrl+z
Expected: both filtration M and filtration Y are reverted to their pre-reset values
Actual: only filtration Y is reset to its pre-reset value, while filtration M remains at 0
Note that the issue is not reproduced if at steps 1 and 2 you adjust them in a different order (M first, then Y)
thanks! Fix in spektrafilm: fix undo for sections by piratenpanda · Pull Request #22273 · darktable-org/darktable · GitHub
and now in master
Not quite sure if it’s a bug or it’s just the best way to represent what’s being shown. In short, when the format is set to 16mm, what’s visible on the smaller version of the photo (e.g. “fit” or “small” zoom option) is quite different from what it looks like when you zoom in to 100%.
Here’s what it looks like with the default 35mm format:
-
The zoomed out version, “fit”
-
The zoomed in version, 100%
Now when I set it to 16mm:
- The zoomed out version, “fit”
- The zoomed in version, 100%, before it’s loaded the full preview
- The zoomed in version, 100%, fully loaded
When exported, the photo looks like the final version (zoomed in, after it’s loaded), but during the editing it looks different, which changes the perception of the photo. In this example, I would want to tone down the blueness of this area, but the exported version actually looks tolerable enough.
The configuration is: default spektrafilm with 1.00 scanner sharpness, vision 200T on vision 2383 paper
I think this may be because of the grain. Coarser grain dilutes the colour more, and when it gets averaged out for a smaller preview, this colour pollution becomes exaggerated. The effect seem even worse on smaller formats
Yeah, and this one is partly on Darktable too I think, the scaling is… I dont want to call it broken, but it feels like it. I accepted to judge the images only at 100% zoom, and export only at the original size too.
When you zoom out you are essentially processing an image of that size (or close to that, @hannoschwalm can tell you precisely). So on say a 1080p monitor, you are processing at most a 720p or even less depending on how zoomed out you are, this has big impacts on some algorithms like sharpening, grain, etc, and why it’s recommended to always check it at 100%, or toggle high quality processing.
If you want the most accurate preview as you say you look at 100% or if zoomed out use the HQ preview… If you are exporting then be sure to select HQ reprocessing to match that view and if you use the default DT preview and like how that looks…then a better match is to turn HQ reprocessing off… Some times I actually prefer the perceived sharpness and contrast of images previewed/exported with the no setting and other times there are detail and color artifacts that are better served with a yes setting… Also you can choose different scaling options in the preferences that will impact how things look so you can experiment with those… Aurelien always seemed to have them set at bicubic even though I think that is considered a simpler scaling aligo but I have followed that and things seem fairly predictable at least on my display, and running DT on Windows…
I understand that. And I think it makes sense as far as sharpening is concerned. But in this case there’s alteration in colour and partially in tonality too, which I’ve never experienced with other modules when comparing the full preview vs the smaller one. But then again I’m not sure if this can be fixed somehow
I’ll check tomorrow
I don’t think this is specific to spektrafilm. Noisy images can also look quite different in the editing preview compared to when High quality Preview is enabled or when exporting.
Finally can get something out of darktable I’m happy with. After years of trying and trying lol. Thank you so much for this module! <3
One quality of life feature alongside the pre-post compression boosts I would like to see is the black level correction. Sometimes I really like the tonal transitions of the Portra Endura paper, but the photo is turning out to be heavy on the shadow information, and the elevated black level really gives it too much fade. In these cases I’m doing a workaround that only God may forgive me for: I’m creating an exposure module instance, placing it after spektrafilm and using the black level correction slider (usually around +0.0015 but it depends on the photo).



















