My theoretical statements were exactly that art is judged in a context and that this isn’t in any way a problem. I also said, in a few more words, that it’s a shitty photo but that fact doesn’t influence whether it’s good or not.
No one has stated that the judgement should/can be done without any context. It’s pretty obvious that a single image can be shit but the series it’s part of great. Same goes for not judging paintings from the 800’s the same as paintings from 2022. They are cultural artefacts.