Great job on the tutorial and explanation!
The retouch module in darktable does work like a charm if you ask me. Simply because it peals off the image into layers, and you adjust the layers accordingly getting a great end result.
If you ever decide to work with darktable, feel free to DM me for any questions. I’ll try to help you the best way I can.
Thank you @sguyader
It’s a good example of educational support, the result is very good
Perhaps there are probably other ways to achieve (with RT) a similar result, if other volunteers wish to participate.
Overall from my point of view, Rawtherapee lacks educational materials, be it Rawpedia, videos, or documents of this type.
This supposes to have in addition to rawpedia and screenshot, adapted support (blog, page facebook, etc.)
Developers are generally not the right people to do this because they are focused on development, how to solve the problem and not how to concretely achieve a given result.
On the other hand, the developers - including me of course - are ready to contribute.
For example, I brought my advice to @XavAL for a complex module like “wavelet”, for a Spanish version of Rawpedia
Some modules are simple and the use almost obvious.
Others are complex, for example “Wavelet”, “Ciecam”, “Retinex”…or “Black and white”… or ??.
Others are not complex, but brings a mode treatment different from the habits, as for example “Local adjustemnts”
Thanks to Jacques (@jdc) I can provide another, simpler, way to select most of the skin but excluding Mairi’s red hair, by using the recently introduced “mask” tool. You can see the screenshot below, showing the area affected by CbDL (in grey) and how it is achieved with the mask tool:
With the mask enabled, there’s no need to using excluding spots on the hair, the only excluding spots are for the eyes and mouth.
At first the use of the mask tool was confusing to me, but if I understand correctly, it works by removing some areas form the initial selection:
when you add the RTspot, it uses the deltaE to “select” the destination pixels (those affected by the filter, here by CbDL), but sometimes such as in this example the deltaE between hair and skin is too small to allow a correct separation
adding the mask will actually allow you to exclude some pixels from the initial selection, based on L(L), C(C ) or LC(H) equalizer. In this example, drawing a narrow notch in the LC(H) curve at the H corresponding to the hair allows to exclude it quite efficiently from the original selection, without affecting the skin selection.
“traditionnal”, with “merge” (I call “blend”), image from mask, and original image. in this case you must use, all sliders - blend, radius, chroma mask, gamma mask, slope, and of course 1, 2 or 3 curves L(L), C(C) , LC(H)
specific Rawtherapee, in this case, as says above by @sguyader , the mask serves to increase the selection capacity by artificially playing on the deltaE.
The image is not change at all, only “deltaE”.
In this case, you must use : 1 ,2 or 3 curves, radius…
If you use the others sliders, I recommand very very small values, because you change the image - of course , its perhaps the goal - but be carefull.
@Chawoosh you need to download a specific build, as the local adjustments are not yet in the main version.
If you’re a Windows user, you can download the latest build from here (look for the “RawTherapee_newlocallab_xxxxxxxx…” build.
Then pamac will do everything for you (checking/downloading dependencies, configuring, compiling and installing).
If you had a previous version of RT installed, it will remove it, but don’t be afraid, the newlocallab branch is not far behind the current dev version, and it is probably ahead of your unstable build.
And if it doesn’t work for you, simply reinstall your usual unstable build and it should replace the newlocallab build.
I’m using aurman, but it’s not important. Git version is installed on my work comp, and don’t updated long time, but unstable was updated every day in a long time. What is important for me - that this feature is in realization.
I did try the local adjustment many months ago. The UI was clearly not finished and hard to use. I did not have time to try the many improvemnt from these last months since.
I’ll try to get a try now as it seems to be far more “polished” yet.
I’m curious to see if “carafife” will do something on this subject. He’s doing a great job on darktable & GIMP. It’s a great thing that he’s starting to make some tutoriel for RT in french !