It has occurred to me as well, but I always got it to work eventually. I thought it was only me. Though I never use the filmstrip: it occurred on the light table.
It may be the darktable mouse hover issue: even if images are selected, if the mouse pointer is hovering over an unselected image, keyboard shortcuts work on the hovered-over image. This includes Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V as well. This means you may not be copying the history you intend to, and may not be pasting it in the history stack(s) you think you are.
Iâve now tested this locally, and it seems to be working fine, I just have to pay attention to this.
I donât think this is explicitly described in the manual. Itâs mentioned for tagging only, I think:
The attached tags section displays tag(s) attached to image(s), where those images are under your mouse cursor (if hovering over an image in the lighttable view); or
currently selected (if not hovering over an image)
I will test this myself, but generally Iâve got a problem with the workflow of DT.
Too many things that require an extra care or getting used to.
For example, I hate the behaviour of the filmstrip that moves when I select the image there, because it self-centres in the middle, always changing the position of the thumbnails based on your selection.
Even if you physically move the filmstrip yourself by a mouse wheel it will re-center again on your selection, messing up my mind-preview of the thumbnails that I had.
I donât count how many times Iâve selected the wrong image when I was in a hurry.
Instead, let me move the filmstrip when I want it, just select the next image⌠donât move.
I tested it in Windows and it only works when your mouse is in the filmstrip.
It doesnât matter if you use ctrl-shift+ or just ctrl+ it wonât paste anything on multiple images if your mouse is not positioned on the filmstrip.
If your mouse is away from the filmstrip it wonât paste anything, regardless of your selection.
If your mouse is positioned on the unselected image - it will paste the settings to that hovered image(!) and not to your selection!
If your mouse is on the selected image(s) it will paste the settings to all selected images - sometimes.
Mouse hover always trumps selections. It has been like this forever. Is it good or bad? Depends on how you feel about. There are several other threads discussing this at great length.
Fair enough, I can understand the hovering behaviour. Like - âdo the paste on the image I hovered because itâs important but donât add it to selectionâ
What I think itâs a bug is that pasting doesnât work if a mouse is outside of the filmstrip.
Your mouse needs to be on the filmstrip even if you use CTRL+SHIFT+V, otherwise the paste wonât go anywhere.
Further, I encountered another bug where the thumbnail displays the pasted version even if you changed the original history to 0 and the image does not have any settings at all.
Isnât it just Ctrl V for paste? I donât think you need the SHIFT.
For what itâs worth, I used to hate the hover behaviour and it got me in trouble quite a few times. But I realized I had to get used to it because it seems to be fairly well established in the software. I barely notice it now because Iâve got the muscle memory. I actually find it can makes things quicker when you know what youâre doing. You can just hover and tap shortcut keys really quickly instead of clicking multiple times. However, I do feel your pain because I remember hating it at first.
Hereâs that bug. Notice how the first thumbnail changes to overexposed, even though the original does not have any.
I donât apply any changes, i just move the filmstrip back and forth.
It reverts back to correct values only when the image is selected, but doesnât last long.
I really do not think that the âfilmstripâ was ever designed for that purpose.
^c/^v works just fine over single and multiple images on the lighttable where groups and individual selected images can be cloned.
Sorry, I never use âCtrl+Shift+Câ âŚ
I select series with Shift+Click and individual images with Ctrl+Click
Then ^C/^V works perfectly well.
It appears that your problem is with the selection process and not with the copy/paste
The selective functions are invaluable. What if one has straightened or cropped the source image? It is very unlikely that pasting that will fit all the other images.
This are the things I most often âselect outâ of my copy paste. There are others. Iâm sure the possibilities are limited only by what people can think of!