As you have provided a lengthy counter-argument, continuing a point-by-point debate would likely be counter-productive.
However, I would like to clarify my point regarding education. When I look for guidance on complex topics like AgX or the base curve, I value the kind of deep, constructive information found here this post Blender AgX in darktable (proof of concept) - #68 by kofa and Blender AgX in darktable (proof of concept) - #97 by Popanz. These are based on real-world experience and technical rigor.
Unfortunately, what I read on darktable.info lacks that personal touch; there is an absence of concrete examples, and the phrasing feels like AI-generated content designed for engagement rather than deep learning.
To be perfectly honest, my ethics prevent me from approving of a page like this one.
To me, this approach feels too ‘merchandised’—the style of an influencer rather than a community contributor. I find it somewhat disrespectful to the developers who have built the actual complexity and power of the software.
I prefer to end my participation in this debate here, as I have no wish to offend anyone during this holiday season.
Greetings from de Luberon,
Christian