Did you see the new lightroom masking?

I am not going for any monthly ransom software, but this looks seriously impressive! GUI looks very neat too.

I quite like how neat the interface looks compare to the cluttered darktable interface which is small (on my 27") and harder to maneuver.

1 Like

Masking by saliency mapping and object detection isn’t new. Couple that with machine learning and we have a compelling package. It is possible in open source as well if someone is willing to put it together.

I mean new as in “new Lightroom tool”. I am aware I can do more or less the same in darktable (without the AI, but often MI works better, even though slower). I really like the interface though.

1 Like

I watched it again on a bigger screen (my mobile’s is super tiny) and I see the image-editor-layer type GUI. It looks like a handy way to view masks at a glance and also allow them to be the basis of new ones. Interface debatable but feature-wise a good thing. I think ART and RT are closer to this than dt, but I haven’t been using these 3 in a long time…

It is a fairly simple picture though, isn’t it?

How does the masking work if, for example, you replace the boy with a chicken, or several chickens? Can it cope with subjects that contain holes or is obscured in some way?

Not sure, but very sure they used a well working sample for the demo and also pretty sure that in reality it won’t be always that smooth.

I believe Lightroom is a RAW editor, like darktable and has no such function (I don’t use LR, so not sure), that’s what PS, AP, Gimp can do. And I think the feature is the AI mask selection, what you do after that is pretty much the same as in all the other editors, including dt.

There was already a ‘select subject’ in photoshop tight?

And the topaz mask tool had this for ages I think

At least the ai sharpen and denoising tools from topaz can do this. It detects what is in the picture, and then you can pick ‘people’ or ‘sky’ or ‘trees’ to mask them for example.

Always good to see it in more tools of course, do om not complaining. But it isn’t new or groundbreaking :).