negadoctor snowy day

As suggested in this thread Negadoctor neewbie asking for Help I did give darktable a try to convert this Kodak Gold 200 negative, made by a Nikon FE + Nikkor 55mm:

20250228-101231__7801720.NEF (26,8 MB)

This file is licensed Creative Commons, By-Attribution, Share-Alike.

This .nef does come from a Nikon D780 (5000 K). Light source was a LED panel (5000 K).

Also scanned with the color Negative digitizer of this camera. But I’m not happy with this jpeg.

Creating a color variant with darktable turned out to be tedious, so I made a black and white picture. I’m very interested to see if you manage to create a good color image with darktable, but black and white is also exciting in the snow.

This black and white picture was taken with these settings.
20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (22,0 KB)

Beware: the module tone equalizer has to be moved upwards by hand.

3 Likes


20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.arp (11.9 KB)

2 Likes

Negadoctor Plays are always a real challenge to me. That’s the best I could achieve.

20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (21,0 KB)

1 Like

Nothing fancy done here. I simply used negadoctor in DT to invert the image. I then exported an xcf file which I opened in GIMP. I then cropped the image in GIMP and applied the auto function for levels to get this result. I didn’t try any further editing on this image yet as I wanted to demonstrate these fundamental steps first.

In this second image I have brought a tiff file from GIMP back into DT and done some tweaks to improve color, sharpen and reduce the grain.


20250228-101231__7801720.tiff.xmp (11.8 KB)
A third attempt adding an instance of color zones module to try and remove the warm color tint in the white snow. The XCF files probably are of little help here as I am now editing a tiff from GIMP.
20250228-101231__7801720.tiff.xmp (12.4 KB)

2 Likes

Out of curiosity I converted the raw to a tiff in Filmulator then into GIMP.
Inverted colour and ran my colour cast reduction plug-in.

The histogram in GIMP indicates that the light (LED) consists of red, green and blue virtually monochromatic sources. Therefore the resultant image can only contain these wavelengths. It would be interesting to know if the result would be different using a light source with a continuous spectrum.

thoughts and comments welcome!

1 Like

The best I was able to achieve


20250228-101231__7801720_RT-2.jpg.out.pp3 (16.8 KB)

1 Like

I tried it again. Better than the last time I think. But still…


20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (16,8 KB)

1 Like


20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (14.3 KB)

2 Likes

20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (19,6 KB)

1 Like

Hello everyone, and thank you very much for trying it out. I have looked at a few of your .xmp files. Many thanks for that.

First, though, I have to admit that the film was probably very badly overexposed with up to 5/3 stops back then.

Today I watched the last video from @s7habo https://youtu.be/G0BTd0fJvwo?si=RlHCux70WwObJ9kP :heart_eyes: and tried the color balance rgb module on this image.

20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (12,4 KB)

I have used Negadoctor a lot, so I always enjoy having a go at these. I just did a simple conversion and basic correction for contrast.

A few observations:

  • There doesn’t seem to be any of the unexposed film strip showing, which makes it much harder to get the film base colour correct.
  • There isn’t much colour in the photo so black and white is probably a really good way to go if you wanted to take it in an artistic direction.
  • It’s very noisy and most of the auto pickers in Negadoctor failed. So this is a very challenging photo for practising Negadoctor.

20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (16.0 KB)

2 Likes

Just for fun, a version without using negadoctor.


20250228-101231__7801720.NEF.xmp (11.6 KB)

Hi, unexposed film strip now showing in this new .nef

and

it is taken in daylight against the sun:

20250306-172939__7801999.NEF (26,6 MB)

Thanks @clennep, that version is much easier to work with. Much less fiddling around in Negadoctor was needed.
This is my “neutral” conversion where I haven’t tried to do anything other than develop the scanned negative. No artistic interpretation given, so it’s meant to be faithful to the original shot. I think the slight blue colour cast in the sky and on the snow is probably realistic to what the scene was like (overcast/snowing).

20250306-172939__7801999.NEF.xmp (15.6 KB)

3 Likes

Yes. :blush::+1: