Nikon D4 vs Canon 1DX same sky photographed in mater of minutes

Hello to all,

I have just photographed a nice sky with large dynamic range and both Nikon and Canon managed nicely. Personally I prefer the feeling of Nikon on those images. Note that I cannot see colours properly (partial colour blindness) yet I insist that Nikon produces better colours on landscapes and Canon better representation of skin tones.

Here are the pictures just touched with RawTherapee:




And here are the RAWs including the .pp3’s if someone wants to play with:
Archive.tar.gz (72.3 MB)

Note that the timestamp of those photos show to be 1h of difference but this is due to wrong setting the time on each camera.

4 Likes

Wow, those are some dramatic skies!

1 Like


Canon EOS-1D X_03-May-23-190430_2490.jpg.out.pp3 (11.5 KB)

Canon EOS-1D X_03-May-23-190456_2491.jpg.out.pp3 (11.5 KB)

NIKON D4_03-May-23-200645_5605.jpg.out.pp3 (11.6 KB)

NIKON D4_03-May-23-200822_5610.jpg.out.pp3 (11.6 KB)

I find the difference between the cameras interesting. It’s quite a lot down to white balance, but there’s something else too. Nice sky anyway!
I’ve processed one from each camera. Nikon first, then tried to more or less match that for the other. dt 4.3



Canon EOS-1D X_03-May-23-190430_2490.CR2.xmp (15.8 KB)
NIKON D4_03-May-23-200645_5605.NEF.xmp (14.0 KB)

3 Likes

One version of each camera…

NIKON D4_03-May-23-200822_5610.NEF.xmp (13.3 KB)

Canon EOS-1D X_03-May-23-190430_2490.CR2.xmp (16.9 KB)

1 Like

I have yet to see anyone provide any credible evidence of CFA spectral sensitivity patterns making any actual significant difference in color rendering when used with a RAW processor that doesn’t do camera-specific hacks to mimic the SOOC JPEG look. (By default, RT does not).

In this particular case:
Not sure if you have a 1DX or a 1DX MkIII - the 1DX MkIII has a DCP color profile available in RT. Nikon D4 has no DCP profile available. If you have a 1DXIII, this would be the biggest contributor to any color rendering differences. Easily fixable via a ColorChecker and https://rawpedia.rawtherapee.com/How_to_create_DCP_color_profiles

1 Like

This is a personal preference as I already mentioned about the colour representation of each camera.

This is a 1DX not any other type. The 2012 one.

Both pair of images have been processed using their DCP profiles from lightroom. The Standard one.

burning sky…

NIKON D4_03-May-23-200645_5605.NEF.xmp (10.8 KB)

2 Likes