Nikon Z users, what are you rocking?

Main difference between the two aside from sharpness is that the f/1.4 has more chromatic aberrations and more busy bokeh, with some of the strongest edges in the bokeh that I’ve seen. Not a bad lens - I own it and bought it last year. I even made a tool to compare out of focus foregrounds and backgrounds. Here’s a comparison with the 50mm f/1.8G (I never tried the f/1.8S) to help you out:

You can see that the Z f/1.4 has very strong edges with aberrations in the OOF background but much smoother out of focus foregrounds.

5 Likes

I don’t know what motivated your sarcasm, but I changed my post to better reflect what I actually meant.

Oh wow that’s crazy, I’ve never seen that either :laughing:

S glass is Nikon’s top of the line. Not something you’d generally complain about🙃

Let’s be honest – this particular S line lens is actually worthy of some complaints. The distortions and vignetting are very likely some of the worst on the market (at least with the 24-70 kind of lenses I’ve come seen across brands)

1 Like

Oh, nothing big, just the “making do” which was funny to me. No harm intended!

3 Likes

Oh, that is a shame, not something I’d expect under the S moniker…

2 Likes

I think you would. I have an X-T3 and even with 26MP it’s very clear when a picture is not sharp due to glass or other reasons. It’s amazing the amount of detail you can render with this resolution when you nail focus, light, and optics.

At least chromatic aberration in popular in videography nowadays :smiley: For some it’s a plus.

Me neither! Honestly it’s a disappointment, but what can I do… I’m relying on good enough corrections that I’ve made for lensfun (they need updating, but man I don’t feel like going out to photograph buildings for this…)

But then, if the 24-70 f/4 S is flawed and you must rely on corrections, what is the “character” are you looking for? As a novice, I’m always puzzled by some shared opinions, asking myself whether I should duly absorb them or not:

  1. too sharp is too sharp, better some character (but you can add a distortion or some blur if you want, while you cannot outperform a lower quality lens in postproduction; in any case, it’s not the lens which makes a photo boring or characterful).
  2. “date the camera, marry the lens”. Applied to your situation: for now, you’re using a low MP sensor for which a high quality lens would be wasted, in the future, you might upgrade the camera and the same lens will come in handy.
  3. good bokeh and not so good bokeh: I’ve learned that it’s very important the way things are out of focus appear when they are out of focus! :slight_smile: I’m still trying to resist this one, because it seems really bonkers. :slight_smile:

It’s mostly the distortion that I really dislike. Vignetting is somewhat okay if it’s not too strong. The character I’m looking for? Hmm… could be just a little of sharpness drop off-center with some TCA perhaps? I don’t know to be honest. I might just end up getting a good lens and focus on other things :smile: (pun not intended)

I also like that in a lens, but in case your lens is “too good”, you can do it in post (contrast equalizer or D&S with a mask). This has the advantage that you can select non-circular areas of interest. Keep it subtle.

1 Like

We discussed this sometime back, the new Nikkor Z lenses appear to have been designed to compromise correctable artifacts in favor of less-correctable ones. Which is why they put correction information in the metadata.

For me, the 24-70/f4 data in lensfun works just fine, the 24-200/f4-6.3 data, not so much.

2 Likes

When I was editing a photo of a tram last year, I noticed that the 35mm correction left a barrel bulge in the center. It turned out most focal length corrections were not great either… so I made my own

1 Like

Nikon should launch the new Z7 III as a photography-only camera—no hybrid features.

1 Like

Hmm, so interested in the corners i hadn’t noticed anything in the center.

Yeah corners aren’t as important to me as I can crop if I really need to get rid of the distortion. If they’re just slightly off I leave them be pretty much…

1 Like

I wouldn’t dump the video side but I wouldn’t improve it beyond the Z5 II , I would also dump the CF express slot in favor of a second SD card slot.

If Nikon hasn’t moved to a sensor >45 mpix, then a new Z7 doesn’t make sense. I don’t think the stacked sensor makes sense, they need to get that 60mpix sensor from Sony.

Yeah I feel like there’s little to improve unless you go big. Even when Z5 III will eventually come out, I have no idea what would it bring to the table to be worth it (I won’t upgrade tho). Maybe a 33Mpx sensor? Or the stacked 24Mpx from the Z6 III perhaps? No idea. This camera is pretty much perfect.

Oh wow, I thought Nikon made their own sensors given their lithography history. All Z cameras use sony sensors?