I feel like a neutral swatch in the foreground (that you could crop out or just shoot a second frame in the same light) would’ve been really helpful. I feel like the light isn’t doing the yellow pepper any favors.
Well I decided to have a quick go at doing a simple edit to compare filmic and sigmoid on this image. With filmic I used auto tune levels and then increased the contrast. With sigmoid I just accepted the default values. I am not trying to rate one method against the other with such a simple processing.
It was in another frame the result being somehow warmer than your wb setting, but i agree the yellow pepper suffers from the bad lighting. The table too doesn’t help.
As far as ETTR is concerned, the specular spots on the peppers (I want to say Paprika, that’s my language I guess? I wouldn’t call these peppers ) are clipped.
Turn everything off except whitebalance, drag the exposure way down and you’ll see faint magenta spots.
Inpaint-opposed does fix it pretty much without fiddling, although I do still see some coloured edge / fringe where I think there shouldn’t be one. Messing around with the white level a small bit and segmentation-based recovery removed all magenta from the clipped highlights eventually.
A non-issue, as the spots are so small and by the time filmic / sigmoid / tone-equalizer is done over there, they’ll end up ‘white’ most likely anyway.
It does make it so that there is no ‘real’ colour information in those bright specular spots. I guess it’s not an issue, but I would’ve exposed it lower, I guess.
It was not an artistic shot, i know. After hours of measurements at vary iso, light conditions and so on, i pointed the camera to the table under the kitchen lamp set the exposure and shot.
Anyway thanks for advices and link.
According to rawdigger there were only a handful of pixels blown out in the specular highlights.
In real situations I wouldn’t worry about some blown out specular lights in favor of a better signal.
Obviously for this shot I should have adopted a different light setup, more diffused light with a softbox perhaps.
Anyway thanks.
P.S.
For the pepper/paprika sorry, but my english is very very limited…
Fixes it right up, except for small magenta circles where the unclipped data stops and the clipped data begins. To fix those fringes I had to use segmentation-based.
But as I said, these small details will probably be fixed by just tone-mapping as well. Small spots like this don’t have to be a problem :).