Quickmask: Gimp2 feature gone in Gimp3?

Whatever I try, I can’t get this simple task done with Gimp3:

  1. Open image
  2. Select something using the selection tool of your choice
  3. Toggle Quick Mask
  4. Filters → Blur → Gaussian Blur (Size 100 or bigger to actually see anything)
  5. Toggle Quick Mask
  6. Use Colors → Curves to make the selected area brighter

With Gimp2, the above created a ‘blurred’ selection, means when you make the selection brighter (or whatever else you’d like to do) the processing doesn’t have ‘hard’ borders but a smooth gradient like change.

For whatever reason this doesn’t work in Gimp3, neither on Linux nor Windows.
Gimp2 is the latest available version, Gimp3 is version 3.0.6 (revision 1).

Any help or references to help or documentation are very welcome!

I can replicate your problem on Windows install. Not sure what the problem is.


Feathering the selection worked, but I am not sure if this will be a suitable workaround for you

1 Like

It is probably the active layer losing focus when the quick mask is toggled on/off. Making the layer active and the curves tool should work. I think (not sure) this has been reported as a bug. A large blur and the selection (crawling ants) might be larger than the canvas.

This 50 second example select - Sendvid I put the selection editor (something I vary rarely use) up to see what exactly happens.

1 Like

Thank you, Terry, for taking the time to recreate my problem and confirming that I am neither nuts nor dumb - or both :+1:

Yes, it drove me crazy.
But I found a solution in your short video (thanks for that :+1:): When I activate the “Merge Filters” option under “Gaussian Blur”, everything works as expected.
I have no idea why I never had to do that in Gimp2.
Thanks a ton, Rich :slightly_smiling_face:

I don’t use GIMP much anymore but when I do the merge filter option often catches me out as this seems relatively new. It is probably a good feature once you get used to it.

There is of course a “help” page

https://docs.gimp.org/3.0/en/gimp-using-layer-effects.html

But in pictures, you can apply a sequence of filters and if they are in that (fx) in the layers dock, go back and change the settings. There are also icons there to apply / delete if you forget the tick box in the filter.

Layer effects can screw up some filters, layer masks, bump map from memory.

1 Like