Recreate old lightroom edit

10 years ago I took this picture while traveling through France. Back then I edited it with lightroom, but I have no clue what I did back then (I was just pulling sliders and maybe a gradient or two)

Here’s the lightroom version in b/w and color


I want to recreate or improve on the image with DarkTable. Here’s my take:

I placed the “color equalizer” module below the “color calibration” module (where I ‘create’ the B/W mix)
This to be able to adjust for example the blue patches to become darker and the yellows to become brighter . Maybe that is not the right way to do it, or maybe it is. Anyway, my aim is a nice graphic B/W image. I like the ‘glow’ of the yellows in the LR b/w version

Here are is the raw file
DSC_1305.NEF (11.0 MB)

DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (28.4 KB)

This file is licensed Creative Commons, By-Attribution, Share-Alike.

5 Likes



DSC_1305_01.NEF.xmp (20,6 KB)
DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (15,3 KB)

2 Likes

If you have not seen it yet…Boris did a 3 part series on BW conversion. It was quite good and demonstrates working with the colors pre conversion…

2 Likes

Thanks. I haven’t seen them yet. Nice conversion, learned something today

Modifying @Popanz is probably going to get you closest to what you had, so I thought about not doing a play. But there is something about this photo that I like. Sorry it is not at ll what you were asking for!


DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (22.8 KB)

3 Likes


DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (10.4 KB)

2 Likes


DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (22.7 KB)

DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (30.8 KB)

2 Likes

Lovely picture, thanks for sharing …
Perhaps a bit overboard, but, as said on another thread, I like clouds, as they come and go …

Made with darktable 5.3 …


DSC_1305_03.NEF.xmp (23.8 KB)


DSC_1305_04.NEF.xmp (46.1 KB)

3 Likes

Here is my edit. It was a bit of fun to play with. BTW, I love the two people and the stop sign. It reminded me a little of Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz. I wish they weren’t chopped off.

In my edit I activated the monochrome module early and then used the CC module. I got this idea for using the color calibration module from @Popanz edit.

I then used the color zones module to teak which areas became lighter or darker based on color. And finally I used a couple of heavy instances of local contrast to give the level of contrast I desired.

DSC_1305_01.NEF.xmp (20.2 KB)

5 Likes


DSC_1305_01.NEF.xmp (21.9 KB)

4 Likes

Also all very nice.

Really nice edits. As usual there are may ways to achieve something in DT
@Terry tbh, during the short stop, an enthusiastic dog and nagging spouse (why is this taking so long) I really did not take my time to compose and scout properly

I use this module more for bringing in some drama than to use it for whitebalance.

Leaving the LR edits of the TO aside…


DSC_1305_01.NEF.xmp (17,8 KB)


DSC_1305_01.NEF.xmp (19,7 KB)

2 Likes

This is my version, thank you


DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (27.5 KB)

1 Like

Looks like a good candidate for histogram equalization in the GIMP.

1 Like

Trying a bit of a pano. Thank you for sharing.


DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (19.9 KB)

Never thought of using that module in that particular way. It was fun messing with it here to see how that could work.

2 Likes


DSC_1305.NEF.xmp (27.7 KB)