Rendering Greens

First time Play Raw poster, be gentle.

I’ve always found it challenging to render green foliage in a picture in a pleasing way. I’ve often missed that aspect of old film prints from my youth, and missed it in more modern digital workflows.

This file is licensed Creative Commons, By-Attribution, Share-Alike.

2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng (26.1 MB)

I’ve been enjoying using the filmsim module in vkdt because I think it does a really good job of this!

Here’s a screenshot of my settings in case anyone is curious to play.

Curious what you all come up with!

9 Likes

So, I first “cheated” by using the agx-emulsion film simulator, but then I tried to redo it “by hand”. Here’s my result, using ART. (The parameters are embedded in the jpg in case someone wonders)

10 Likes

Here is my attempt in DT 5.1. I used the color zones module to set the final exposure for the greens and the tree trunk because I wanted to subdue the building in the background.
2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (12.5 KB)

6 Likes

I could make it darker, if that’s what you want.

darktable 5.0.1


2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (8.9 KB)

4 Likes


2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (13.8 KB)

2 Likes

@jedsmith You really took no chances of blown highlights with this photo :smiley: (very pretty picture btw)

I usually desaturate the greens a little bit and decrease their brightness, otherwise I tend to find them quite harsh.

Here’s my attempt with darktable and agx tone mapper


2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (15.8 KB)

3 Likes

I used to hate processing greens, but I’ve learned to embrace them. I realized that I like them darker and with more cyan than how they often come straight out of camera. Bright neon greens are not pleasant to me.

Thanks for sharing this nice pic!

2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (12.1 KB)

4 Likes

Felt it needed to go a tinge towards yellow (so shifted that way). Also used luma invert overlay to open up the shadow details again as well as enhanced the contrast. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

Rendering greens is often a question of personal preferences.


2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (23,4 KB)

5 Likes

Adjusted from my first post: Toned down the greens and reduced the overall brightness.

darktable 5.0.1


2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s_01.dng.xmp (9.9 KB)

1 Like


2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (23.4 KB)

4 Likes

My version…

2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (22,7 KB)

3 Likes

Rawtherapee and GIMP

1 Like

Here is a version with darktable xmp (6.5 KB), and agx-emulsion.
Using data from Kodak Portra 800 (Push 2) and Kodak Supra Endura.

6 Likes


2025-03-15-17h20m54-34.jpg.out.arp (11.1 KB)

1 Like


2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.xmp (32.7 KB)

1 Like

2025-03-15-17h20m54.00s.dng.arp (13.5 KB)

2 Likes

Copied your jpeg and did it in gimp, then cropped.

2 Likes