Testers wanted: experimental Slang GPU path for darktable (Metal/Vulkan)

Thanks to everyone who has tested so far. Here’s where things stand.

Steady-state export time per image (median of exports 2-5), Slang vs OpenCL on the same machine. Lower ratio is better for Slang.

mire1.cr2 (10 MP), the standard benchmark

GPU OS Slang OpenCL Slang / OpenCL
Apple M4 Max macOS 86 ms 175 ms 0.49
Apple M5 Pro macOS 124 ms 205 ms 0.60
AMD Radeon Pro 5700 XT (iMac) macOS 145 ms 199 ms 0.73
AMD Radeon Pro 5500M (MacBook Pro) macOS 298 ms 367 ms 0.81
AMD Radeon Pro 5300 (iMac) macOS 341 ms 407 ms 0.84
NVIDIA RTX 3060 Ti Linux 133 ms 220 ms 0.60
NVIDIA RTX 4060 Laptop Linux 156 ms 255 ms 0.61
NVIDIA RTX 3050 Ti Laptop Linux 235 ms 324 ms 0.72
Intel Iris Xe (i7-1165G7) Linux 562 ms 1111 ms 0.51
Intel Iris Xe (i7-1365U) Windows 913 ms 1833 ms 0.50
Intel UHD 620 Linux 1597 ms 2223 ms 0.72

61 MP Sony raw (larger image, so the denoise module runs in tiles)

GPU OS Slang OpenCL (ROCm) Slang / OpenCL
AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT Linux 0.91 s 1.37 s 0.67
AMD Radeon 780M (integrated) Linux 3.74 s 5.03 s 0.74

Slang is faster than OpenCL on every machine tested so far, and its output matches OpenCL within the usual tolerance (max dE about 1.2-1.5, average below 0.001). The Radeon 780M started at 1.8x slower than OpenCL; @da-phil’s patches and logs got it to where it is now.

Still being worked on

  • On integrated AMD GPUs, up to about 1.5 s of each 61 MP export went on re-allocating GPU memory. A fix is in the latest nightly; a rerun on a Radeon 780M will show how much it saves. @da-phil
  • On Intel Macs, the first export after installing takes about 30 s while the GPU kernels are prepared; later launches are fast. A fix that cuts this to about 3 s is being tested.

Want to test? The nightly builds (Linux AppImage, Windows, Apple silicon macOS) are at Release Darktable nightly build 20261108 · nicknezis/darktable · GitHub. The benchmark instructions are in tools/slang-bench/README.md on the slang-benchmark branch. Please post your summary.md, and mention your driver version. Machines not covered yet would be especially useful: AMD discrete cards on Windows, Intel Arc, and older NVIDIA cards.

6 Likes