darktable documentation: add links to Youtube

Maybe this is already discussed before… So I am sorry if a decision is already made.

Would it be an idea to include references to good video resources explaining certain topics or modules (e.g., from Boris and Bruce) in the Darktable documentation, so that new users — or users who prefer watching videos over reading — can more easily find good explanations?

There is a topic about Planet Darktable, which might fit the bill somewhat. Personally, I’d be slightly hesitant about linking to channels, even if they are good, because it will be a form of endorsement, and you’ll forever have to monitor that channel and its content to prevent a situation where the channel gets deleted or turns to shit. Having an aggregating page like Planet means you only have to keep the links in one spot, and as a bonus you’ll have a wider range of subjects, and a wider range of media — not everybody prefers video.

1 Like

The down side of this, is while Planet Darktable is very nice, it is not really grouped or so, so you keep on searching, which is harder for new users

2 Likes
2 Likes
1 Like

Let me clarify what I am proposing. Yes, it is not that there are no references to other resources. Thank you for sharIng.

My suggestion is that in the documentation, for example on the page of the color balance rgb module a section is added say additional resources or useful resources with links to YouTube or other good resources, that actually explain how to use the color balance rgb module.

This makes the documentation - I think - more useable for people that prefer other methods than reading to understand what a certain module or function does.

Regarding the endorsement. Yes, that might been a thing. But that can be handled by a notice that it a not to endorse these other resources but about helping the user.

I’d say no because:

  1. We don’t want to endorse some channels
  2. Video content tends to age poorly
  3. YouTube as a platform just keeps getting worse
  4. Finding new videos is painful
3 Likes
  1. More maintenance to keep the content and link aligned.
3 Likes

Yes, but this applies to the docs it self as well, it requires maintenance.

I very much agree on that!

Exactly that is one of there reasons to do this… Finding videos is painful, even more for new users…

Pretty much none of the darktable devs or documentation authors release youTube videos, but we do write code / documentation. So the documentation is in our control but youTube is not. Plus I’d want to watch a youTube video before endorsing it and I do not intend to do that.

So you’d like someone else to suffer. I understand :wink:

1 Like

Actually, I had been thinking to contribute to darktable in this way. Helping new users to make sense of it all. But seems that there is no support adding that the documentation. So suggestion cancelled.

You can still do that. There are other places than the documentation to share videos. We’re not saying that it wouldn’t be useful, just that we don’t want to maintain it in the manual.

1 Like

Make a YouTube playlist and share it

1 Like

Yep, that is an idea… but not one that really helpful. The problem is that searching on YouTube is a disaster. And not helpful for new people into darktable. And YouTube is not organised, that is whole problem…

I can understand that it not desirable in the documentation. I will think of another way.

There’s been ideas tossed around in this topic about that: Pixls.us Home Page - Does it need changing?

I had suggested reposting YouTube videos with a brief summary. Providing a playlist could be useful too.

Putting this type of stuff in the documentation isn’t a great idea for reasons already discussed in this topic, but that doesn’t mean it’s not valuable.

1 Like

I think planet darktable is the way forward. New users could click on a link and see other contributions by the author (especially youtube). Should new users be spoonfed? I’m not an expert but I do like exploring this fascinating software and planet darktable is a great finding tool.

I like planet darktable. Very happy it is here!

But is unorganised. Just a long list of (potential) good resources. That doesn’t help if you are new. Or is you are looking for specific thing. It is a really great list of ‘what is currently going on in the world of darktable’ it is very bad in finding out 'how do I use the ‘module x’

1 Like

Dare I mention the AI acronym? I’ve found them helpful and Gemini often includes youtube links.
But isn’t the researching part of the processing fun? Seeing what someone else has done (especially in playraw) and gone wow must try that!

Please no.

2 Likes