Dealing with Blue Background

I’m having trouble working with the blue background and getting the image to pop — I’d love to see your edit.
JPEG is a direct export from darktable with no edits. Has only default adjustment -Agx is the tone mapper.

This file is licensed Creative Commons, By-Attribution, Share-Alike.


IMG_5406.CR3 (35.7 MB)

5 Likes


IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (20.6 KB)

6 Likes

darktable 5.4.1 with FilmicRGB


IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (8.1 KB)

4 Likes

Thank you.

Why not edits? The whole purpose of darktable (and most raws software) is for you to develop your image.

1 Like

My try with DT 5.5, AGX, attenuate the blue and Base Curve to pop

Blue Background - Bird - IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (13.7 KB)

An alternative, added a monochrome touch

1 Like

This is a simple edit using base curve fusion for the back lit bird. I find this technique is often successful and easy with these difficult lighting conditions.
IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (11.6 KB)

2 Likes


Sigmoid version
IMG_5406_01.CR3.xmp (20.2 KB)

1 Like

IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (18,2 KB)

4 Likes

Thank you for the play,

With ART, GIMP and G’MIC:

1 Like

Great shot! love birds of prey, but can’t work this one out… I don’t think it’s a Spawk, but what?? Maybe a male Spawk… Hawks normally have yellow eyes… Although male Spawks do have slightly more orange eyes… Not a Goshawk… What is it??? Where is it? Europe or States or Africa?

Here’s my go… RT-dev with GHS (not too much else to get the blues looking OK on my poor screens… Hope they’re OK on mobile/other screens)


IMG_5406.jpg.out.pp3 (19.0 KB)

My final edit: it’s a young male Sparrowhawk… Final decision… Or phone a friend… No I’m going with that. :crossed_fingers:

3 Likes


IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (15.6 KB)

4 Likes


IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (23.2 KB)

11 Likes

Filmic RGB

IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (18.9 KB)

3 Likes

My version…

IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (23,3 KB)

4 Likes

A quick edit but I already like Thomas version better than mine.


IMG_5406.jpg.out.pp3 (16.4 KB)

5 Likes

Awesome photo @rmishra!

For this sort of image I think about the following ways to increase “pop” or contrast in the following ways:

Subject Color vs Non-subject Color

Maximize differences between the subject (hawk) and the non-subject (branches and sky) in the realm of color: saturation, hue, etc.
Since there is a natural color contrast between the warm bird and the blue sky, I enhanced this using the primaries rgb module. I shifted reds to orange, green to yellow, and blue to cyan, which effectively compresses the colors of the image to accentuate the orange/cyan difference.

I then used selective masking with color balance rgb to increase saturation in the hawk and reduce it everywhere else. I used one instance for increasing saturation of the hawk, and one instance to decrease saturation everywhere else.

I also used the color equalizer to shift the colors of the hawk more orange, and the color of the sky more cyan. I also used this module to reduce the saturation of colors that were not present in the hawk. Since each hue can be modified separately, only one instance is necessary for this step.

Subject Contrast vs Non-subject Contrast

Using the contrast equalizer module, I reused the mask selection from the color editing, inverted the mask, and then reduced the mid to high frequency contrast in the image everywhere other than the hawk.

Subject Sharpness

I again reused the selective mask for the hawk in the Diffuse & Sharpen module to add sharpening to the hawk.

Vignetting

I added another instance of the exposure and contrast equalizer modules. I used oval drawn masks in both to reduce the brightness and contrast in the edges of the image. This helps remove interest from the edges of the image (like details tree bark or just business) so the viewer eyes naturally linger on the hawk more. This method is really useful because it is reasonably realistic since this is something that naturally happens with lenses.

Etc.

I started this edit by making the image quite bright, which naturally reduces the impact of the blue sky, since AgX desaturated the highlights. I also added grain to help hide any unnatural, selective edits. I could have pushed all the components of this edit much harder, but I am a sucker for natural-looking edits, and wanted to do what I could to increase pop without sacrificing the beauty of nature.

This was a super fun image to edit. Thank you for sharing!


IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (104.2 KB)

10 Likes

IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (18,7 KB)

5 Likes

This was nice picture and fun to edit, thank you!
I’m trying out (and trying to understand all tools included) new workflow @jdc suggests with Rawtherapee dev build.


IMG_5406.jpg.out.pp3 (31.0 KB)

6 Likes


IMG_5406.CR3.xmp (62,5 KB)

3 Likes