Root and Branch

Have I said before how much I like trees?

I captured this one on a coastal walk last year. I’m trying to get a monochrome treatment and after a number of attempts this is the best I can do. I’m still not entirely happy with it but I can’t put my finger on why. Would love to see some alternatives…

2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.cr2 (32.3 MB)
2022-01-31-11.58.58.0_02.cr2.xmp (31.0 KB)

Edit is from the current development version of darktable.

This file is licensed Creative Commons, By-Attribution, Share-Alike.

11 Likes

My version…

2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.cr2.xmp (19.0 KB)

9 Likes

GREAT capture. I didn’t change much at all. dt 4.4.2


2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.cr2.xmp (6.9 KB)

4 Likes

2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.cr2.xmp (14.3 KB)

3 Likes

Following in the B/W lane, I’ve taken the sky down somewhat and lowered the general contrast to make the tree (texture) imm better stand out in the image. (That bright sky in the OP catches too much of my attention).
I’ve also cleaned up a little on light stones in the foreground that may otherwise also draw some attention.


2022-01-31-11.58.58.0_02.cr2.xmp (12.3 KB)

2 Likes

Nice. I’m surprised how much I like the lower contrast version and it’s not something I’d normally consider doing.

@elstoc I love the picture pre-BW! I got some “dramatic” vibe in the BW version, and tried to roll with it.
I tried to preserve the luminescence of your bright sky, as I felt its’ contrast with the shadows is awesome. (while tried to emphasize the shadows). + slightly rotated the image
edit: NO! Rotation doesn’t do good to the image, it’s cropping some areas.


RootAndBranches.cr2.pp3 (13.8 KB)

darktable 4.4.2


2022-01-31-11.58.58.0_02.cr2.xmp (17.3 KB)

3 Likes

Thank you for the play.

My edit with ART:


2022-01-31-11.58.tif.out.arp (14.8 KB)

3 Likes


2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.cr2.xmp (13.9 KB)

3 Likes


2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.jpg.out.pp3 (13.9 KB)


2022-01-31-11.jpg.out.arp (12.1 KB)
In ART 1.21 with the T-MAX 100 simulation.

1 Like

GIMP. Luminosity mask plug-in to try and increase contrast on the trunk and branches of the tree.
Increase in colour channel separation.

3 Likes

Gave it a try. :slight_smile:


2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.cr2.xmp (16.1 KB)

2022-01-31-11.58.58.0_01.cr2.xmp (17.4 KB)

6 Likes

2022-01-31-11.58.58.0.cr2.xmp (12.4 KB)

1 Like