Snow is white...

There is a standard example in theories of truth, which reads, “The statement ‘snow is white’ is true, if and only if, snow is white”.

I was out early this morning looking for a good sunrise (didn’t happen, complete cloud cover). However, I did get this shot. The lights at the end of the bridge are old-fashioned sodium ones. The question is, should I correct the lighting to make the snow a blue-white colour, or should I leave it as it was illuminated?


_CTW7361.NEF (49.1 MB)
_CTW7361.NEF.xmp (8.6 KB)

These files are licensed Creative Commons, By-Attribution, Share-Alike.

6 Likes

I’d say that that’s The Universal Dilemma.
It depends… I mean, compare your version, above,
with this “rectified” version:

Have fun!
Claes in Lund, Sweden

4 Likes

All the light that hits the flakes bounces back in all directions. There is no part of the light that is absorbed. So, in the same way that the light arrives, with the color of…, it leaves the flake with the same characteristics.

My version…

_CTW7361.NEF.xmp (16.8 KB)

Hi there,
been tooling around with mono blend modes - this is average, think it gives a little more than normal


Thanks for the play

_CTW7361_mono_avg.NEF.xmp (7.5 KB)

2 Likes

IMO, it should be shown as it was illuminated.

4 Likes

For me it is more or less a question of your artistic intent. In such situations I would go for a rendition that fits best the context of what I would like to transport as the “message” of the picture. By the way, a really nice shot :blush:

My fun


GIMP_L-a-b

6 Likes

So the snow is white and I love the blue color that this brings out.
_CTW7361.NEF.xmp (7.9 KB)

2 Likes

That’s a serious JPG… 23MB… :slight_smile:

My eyes just couldn’t come to embrace the “orange” versions…maybe my screen not being calibrated but even in a strong light it just didn’t “speak to me” :slight_smile:

Funny I just auto wb and added a little exposure and I actually found that pleasing…I guess its not accurate but I prefer it to the alternative…

1 Like

My Bad,
I must remember to make a smaller screen/internet friendly JPG file next time. I also did not like the orange look, so I white balanced on the snow and use tone equalizer to brighten the snow itself. Lets test out this 25% size JPG for posting here.

2 Likes

White…?

_CTW7361_01.NEF.xmp (13.3 KB)

7 Likes

a blue and gold version could look nice? the background in blue like the corrected versions here combined with the snow and bridge lit by the sodium lamps as golden

Yeah, that was my Idea also - kinda like “meet half the way”. It got definitely more colorful, though …
¯\_(ツ)_/¯

_CTW7361.NEF.xmp (36.7 KB)

edit: “meet” - not “meat” :tired_face:

4 Likes

i like this best! although of course it’s all down to personal choice and intention with the picture

1 Like

This brings back memories of the (in)famous dress.

2 Likes


My attempt.

1 Like

I love this sort of conundrum…

Yeah, you can white balance this to make the bridge look “normal”, but the background goes rather blue. So, given I wanted a portrait crop that made the background more evident, I stuck with “as-shot” WB:

_CTW7361

1 Like

_CTW7361.NEF.xmp (10.4 KB)

First try

1 Like

As seen in a children’s book. Just playing around…

1 Like