Spare battery has swelled!?!

When I bought the X-T1, quite a few years ago,
it came with one original (Fuji) battery. I wanted
a back-up battery as well, and picked a Patona
(having a much nicer price).

I have used both of them regularly, and charged one
while the other sat in the camera.

Until today. The Patona has swelled so much that it
cannot be inserted into the battery chamber any longer.

Is this quite common?
Is it due to the fact that I bought a cheaper brand?

Have fun!
Claes in Lund, Sweden

1 Like

I’m willing to bet it’s a cheaper (manufactured) battery. This seems to happen more often in third-party batteries unfortunately…

Here in the states there is a 3rd party company called Wasabi. I’ve had zero problems with their batteries.

1 Like

In this post (in German), an original Olympus battery and one from Patona (and a no-brand one) were dissected. The OEM battery had a much better design than either third-party battery, with solid casing, nice electronics, and a bit of margin for swelling.

(Google Translate)

Patona installed the best cells. A decent electronics like Olympus and they would be absolutely first choice - even for the price of an original battery. Despite the defective battery, Olympus delivered the best manufacturing quality. Everything is in its place, everything is as it should be and the whole thing is safe. You can see it: even leaked electrolyte cannot inflate or set fire to the battery case. This is because Olympus realized the gluing with foam rubber strips on the edge, not in the middle. And that’s why the bags can inflate up to a millimeter on both sides without anything happening.

[…] The Patona can be considered as an emergency replacement if you don’t use it more than once a month. Then you will also last for the life of the camera. Because the Patonas are actually killed by the charging electronics. As long as you don’t [charge] them, they are great….

On the electronics found in the two third-party batteries:

After all, the cells have a center tap, which is led to the board on B1. Unfortunately, it goes to a 470 ohm resistor and not to a charging electronics, which explains the short lifespan of the batteries. Again there is no load balancing. It was already clear that there was no thermal resistance.

2 Likes

Be careful! A swollen battery may explode – one reason for battery swelling is that gases are released inside it. I’d take it to an e-waste disposal site as soon as possible.

Also see: What to do with a swollen battery - iFixit

5 Likes

Have a look here The Great Battery Brawl – Dom Varney Fotoatelier . . . The Gnosis of Light, the Praxis of Glass and here http://ultralightphotography.net/gear/fuji-cameras/everything-you-wanted-to-know-about-np-w126-batteries/
Very nice documented and explained.

2 Likes

YMMV, I have an OEM Sony battery and two 3rd party Patona batteries. I’ve used them extensively for the last three years and sometimes I even think they last longer than the original one.

Thanks for instructive links! Brrrrr.
One of the revealing things I learnt is
that Patona seems to have a resistor
in a position where the original has
a thermistor. A small thing, yes, but
since the thermistor assists in cutting
off charging if the thing gets too hot,
the lack of it does not sound sufficiently
safe.

1 Like

Yeah, sometimes knowing to much is not good :wink:

@Daniel_Catalina
… and knowing too little can be lethal.

I followed @mbs’ advice and took a trip
to the city’s e-waste disposal dump this
afternoon to get rid of it. Just to be on
the safe side.

From now on, only genuine, original parts for me.

Thanks, all!

2 Likes

Safety first. Not all batteries are made equal, even from the same manufacturer. Same with other hardware like cameras. There are bound to be duds. Sometimes I get unlucky a few times in a row.

Yes most probably the cheaper one swells up really soon. In case of batteries we should never ever consider cheaper option. Even with cheaper batteries we are damaging our devices as the voltage are not accurate enough and there are many other things. So we should always buy a genuine battery in case of our devices.

When it comes to third-party batteries, there’s always a risk; however, some brands present a higher risk than others (and there are many articles dotted around that can help in this regard).

Having said this, I’ve used a very cheap battery (along side my official Fuji-branded battery) for almost 10 years with no issues whatsoever; whereas a friend if mine had a genuine Fuji battery swell in the chamber of his X-T3.

Having said that ‘having said this,’ :wink: it’s important to remember that you’ll likely invalidate any warranties should anything go wrong.

The take-aways from all this? If your equipment is new and expensive, the risks aren’t worth it; however, if your camera is quickly approaching retirement age (like mine), it may not be worth investing in an official branded option and the risks may be more acceptable — just be sure to do some careful research to keep said risks to an acceptable minimum.

What I tend to do is charge my batteries well in advance; that way, there’s little chance they’ll get stuck in the chamber, and I can disgaurd them straight away if there’s any evidence of swelling or other damage. My other bit of advice is to stay away from ‘in-camera’ charging at all costs, and NEVER leave batteries to charge unattended.

Another important thing: if using Fuji-branded batteries, only charge them with a Fuji charger.

DISLAIMER: the ‘risks,’ I am refering to here are those that relate to the issues caused by swelling batteries to the camera only; NO risks to your health and safety are EVER worth taking!

2 Likes

I’ve been using ‘patona platinum’ without issues and they seem well rated(4*) in the comparison linked above. @Claes was this a regular Patona or some other one?

1 Like

Not tried those, but I’m about to try one of the ExPro Whites I bought a while ago — my ‘el cheapo’ I refered to above has finally given up, which is what reminded me of this thread (after 10 years of use, it doesn’t hold it’s charge any longer).

1 Like

@hatsnp It was regular Patona.

1 Like

When my Canon batteries give up the ghost I might consider third party batteries (done so in the past), but they’re chip-ID-ed so the camera knows if they’re not Canon and will complain. Since this was an all-new group purchase I bit the bullet and paid for Canon batteries at the time. Maybe not again, since I’m out of warranty now.

2 Likes

Just keep in mind that the risk of fire is real. Most cheap batteries will never cause any problems, but some will. There’s been 22 battery-started fires in New York City just this year: FDNY issues warning about lithium-ion battery fires - CBS New York

Sadly, the vast majority of third-party batteries for 2S packs appear to be skipping basic stuff like cell balancing.

As a result, even if the cells might be decent, they’re abused by poor BMS.

I’m assuming that the Fuji batteries, like many mirrorless and SLR batteries, are 2S packs with the expectation that the pack BMS does balancing.

My understanding is that you shouldn’t store lithium ion batteries fully charged (and in fairness you don’t actually say you do that). My Canon manual says charge them the day you need them or the day before. Of course that’s not always possible.

If not using for a while, it’s said store them about 50% charged.

3 Likes