Trouble getting red leaves match color

The tree leaves in backyard park is getting really red so went out and took some pictures.
Trouble is I can’t get a satisfying color grading with DT.
DSC07054.ARW (24.1 MB)
DSC07054.ARW.xmp (6.0 KB)

To put it in perspective, here’s the preview jpg extracted from raw file, which looks closer to real life:

Have fun color grade it!

This file is licensed Creative Commons, By-Attribution, Share-Alike.

6 Likes

No color grading just some exposure and tone eq…maybe making it lighter than when you took the shot…but this was much like when I went for a walk here in Southern Ontario today near the campus… a sort of orange red…with the sunlight…

maybe with a little primaries adjustment closer to this…

But again I am making it lighter than you have shown from the jpg…

5 Likes

Here’s my take on it.


DSC07054.ARW.xmp (29.8 KB)

6 Likes


DSC07054.ARW.xmp (18,1 KB)

7 Likes

Please be gracious. I fear fisheyes are not my cup of tea…
:cold_sweat:

DSC07054.ARW.xmp (20,5 KB)

8 Likes

Same for me, I think that this scene works better de-fisheyed if that’s even a word.

1 Like

But un-de-fisheyed version is less common and perhaps can look more interesting?

Being able to see both/different approaches here is a luxury, thanks to all!

2 Likes

Hello,

Personally, this is why I no longer use the filmic module. Okay, it’s subjective…
I find that sigmoid respects colors better from the start. For this beautiful shot, I used the “smooth” preset by increasing the contrast a little, it highlights the red colors of autumn while preserving a natural sky.


DSC07054_01.ARW.xmp (16.5 KB)
Greetings from Brussels,
Christian

8 Likes

I’d also prefer it without fish :fish:

This is how I would have done it without having seen @Popanz 's version


DSC07054_RT-6.jpg.out.pp3 (17.0 KB)

3 Likes

DSC07054.ARW.xmp (13.3 KB)

5 Likes


DSC07054.ARW.xmp (10.4 KB)

1 Like

My version…

DSC07054.ARW.xmp (23,0 KB)

7 Likes

In my first version I only tried to match the tree color (sorry for the ca), here is another edit.

DSC07054.ARW.xmp (13.4 KB)

3 Likes

I went out and took another look, and you are right the trees are more orange than I remembered.

Well I thought I would challenge myself by bringing only a prime lens, and it doesn’t get more challenging than a fisheye😄

un-de-fisheyed😄


This would be a more normal view from a phone camera

6 Likes

Thanks Christian. I guess I really need to practice more with sigmoid.

1 Like

Its a very good option to use but there are photos where filmic can look better so its just a matter of getting to know the performance of both… If say as I do you use filmic v5 with no color preservation and adjust the curve shoulders trying either the default settings at hard or move them to safe then you can really configure/tune that version of filmic with the latitude, the look curve to tweak color, and often bump the contrast as you won’t go quickly to being clipped when it is on safe vs hard…

1 Like

Keep in mind that with sigmoid you may want to reduce the “preserve hue” slider to get better red colors.